roofy

3-bedroom apartment for rent in Prospect Heights

557 Carlton Ave Unit 2, Prospect Heights, Brooklyn, New York, NY, 11238

$8,500/mo
Rent per month · in USD
Size
—
Available
Now

About this home

Apartment for rent in Prospect Heights, Brooklyn: 3 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms. Rent $8,500/mo. Built in 1915.

From the original listing · Realtor.comShow

A rare opportunity to experience the grandeur of classic Brooklyn brownstone living. Set across the upper two levels of an elegant two-family residence, this expansive three-bedroom, two-bathroom duplex at 557 Carlton Avenue seamlessly blends historic architectural character, remarkable proportions, and the flexibility of modern living. Dating to the early 20th century, the home is a celebration of Brooklyn's architectural heritage. Rich original hardwood floors, beautifully preserved woodwork, substantial moldings, soaring ceilings, and oversized windows create an atmosphere of timeless sophistication. Particularly striking is the magnificent curved wooden staircase, with its intricately carved balustrade and sweeping handrail, an architectural centerpiece that speaks to the craftsmanship of another era. The lower level of the duplex is thoughtfully arranged for both everyday comfort and entertaining. A generously proportioned, front-facing living room is bathed in natural light, while the rear of the residence features a dedicated dining area adorned with an elegant crystal chandelier and an adjoining windowed kitchen with abundant cabinetry and stainless steel appliances. Conveniently located beside the kitchen is an in-unit washer and dryer, while a full bathroom with a bathtub completes this level. Upstairs, the residence unfolds into an exceptionally spacious and versatile collection of rooms. The rear-facing primary bedroom offers a peaceful retreat, complemented by two additional bedrooms and a separate bonus room ideally suited for a home office, private library, reading lounge, or creative studio. A second full bathroom, featuring a glass-enclosed shower, completes the upper level. Throughout, the generous room dimensions and adaptable layout offer an uncommon degree of flexibility. The location is every bit as compelling as the residence itself. Situated along one of Prospect Heights' quintessential brownstone-lined blocks, 557 Carlton Avenue places you at the intersection of Brooklyn's architectural history and its most vibrant cultural destinations. Barclays Center and Atlantic Terminal are just moments away, offering exceptional transportation connectivity and convenient access to Manhattan and beyond. The celebrated neighborhoods of Fort Greene, Clinton Hill, and Crown Heights are all within easy walking distance, along with the neighborhood's acclaimed restaurants, independent cafes, boutiques, and cultural institutions. Prospect Park, Grand Army Plaza, the Brooklyn Museum, Brooklyn Botanic Garden, and the Brooklyn Public Library's landmark Central Library are also nearby. An extraordinary combination of historic character, generous living space, and an exceptional Prospect Heights address, 557 Carlton Avenue offers a distinctly Brooklyn living experience that is increasingly difficult to find.

Description from Realtor.com, shown as published there. See the original listing

Roofy listing score

Grade C, 58/100 · Fairly complete

How complete and honest this listing is, from what the source sites show and Roofy’s own checks. It isn’t a rating of the home or the agent. How the score works

  • Photos25/25
    • Full points: 25 photos15/15
    • Full points: Large, clear photos (about 1,000 px)10/10
  • Details11/20
    • Full points: Price stated3/3
    • Full points: Bedrooms stated2/2
    • Full points: Bathrooms stated2/2
    • No points: No size0/2
    • No points: No move-in date0/2
    • No points: No lease length0/1
    • No points: No pet policy0/1
    • Full points: Laundry mentioned1/1
    • No points: Heat and utilities not mentioned0/1
    • No points: No amenities listed0/2
    • Full points: Description of 404 words3/3
  • True cost7/15
    • No points: Broker fee not stated0/8
    • Full points: Price in line with similar homes in its ZIP code7/7
  • Accuracy9/15
    • Nothing to compare: Listed on one site, nothing to compare3/6
    • Problem: Differs from city records (built 1880, 2 homes)2/5
    • Full points: Confirmed on its source site 4 days ago4/4
  • Legal6/10
    • Full points: No fair-housing problems found in the wording6/6
    • Problem: The agent’s license is not active0/4
  • Trust0/15
    • No points: Not claimed on Roofy by the agent or owner0/10
    • No points: The agent is not verified on Roofy0/5

Listed this home? Claim your agent page to add the trust points.

Scored Nov 2, 2026 · Score version 1. No one can pay to change a score.

Fees and terms

Estimated cash to move in$17,020

First month $8,500, a one-month deposit $8,500 (the most New York allows) and a $20 screening fee. Under the FARE Act the listing broker’s fee is not yours to pay.

Compared with the area

Asks $8,500/mo, 42% above the median asking rent for 3-bedroom rentals in 11238.

Median here
$6,000/mo
19 listings, last 90 days

Asking prices of listings on Roofy and listing sites in the last 90 days, not signed leases or sale prices. One currency, never converted.

More about 11238

Location

Location as the listing shows it.Open in Google Maps

Nearby transit

  • Bergen St2 3 45 min walk
  • 7 AvB Q7 min walk
  • Atlantic Terminal (LIRR)Babylon City Terminal Zone Far Rockaway Hempstead Long Beach Port Jefferson West Hempstead8 min walk

Nearby public schools · District 13

Distance only, not school zones. Check the zoned school with NYC Public Schools.

The building

2 units · 3 floors · built 1880 · 1 more home listed here

Building record (NYC)

NYC records as of Nov 1 (weekly)

557 Carlton Avenue · BBL 3-01137-0011 · built 1880 · 2 units

Roofy building score 96/100 · Well keptAbout the building, from HPD violations. Not an inspection.
Building type
Two-family home
Open HPD violations
None
Heat complaints
0 this season
Complaints, last 12 months
0
Rent stabilization
None in 2018–2024 tax bills
Last sale (12-month file)
No sales in our 12-month file

No open immediately hazardous (Class C) violations.

See the full building record

Public NYC records about the building, not about the person listing it. Buyers and renters can see them on city websites too. Source: NYC Open Data (DCP PLUTO, HPD, DOF).

Added to Roofy Oct 29, 2026Last checked on Realtor.com Oct 29, 2026Roofy doesn’t verify listings. Never send money before seeing a home.

From Jason Abrishami

Jason Abrishami’s page →