roofy
For saleHouseNewScore 73

3-bedroom house for sale in West New Brighton-Silver Lake-Grymes Hill

433 Sheffield St, West New Brighton-Silver Lake-Grymes Hill, Staten Island, New York, NY, 10310

$699,999
Asking price · in USD
Size
1,304 ft² (121 m²)
Available
Now

About this home

House for sale in West New Brighton-Silver Lake-Grymes Hill, Staten Island: 3 bedrooms, 1 bathroom, 1,304 ft². Asking price $699,999. Built in 1950.

From the original listing · Realtor.comShow

Welcome to this charming 3/4-bedroom brick Cape ideally situated in the heart of West Brighton, offering classic character, comfortable living space, and an oversized 50 x 100 lot with a spacious backyard with pool. The inviting first floor features a welcoming living room with a wood-burning fireplace, hardwood floors, a generously sized eat-in kitchen with a convenient door leading directly to the backyard, and two bedrooms. Upstairs, you'll find two additional rooms, providing flexible space for family, guests, bedrooms, a home office, or whatever suits your needs. The full basement offers excellent potential and is finish-able, providing an opportunity to create additional living, recreation, office, or entertainment space. A built-in one-car garage adds valuable convenience along with additional storage potential. Step outside to enjoy the expansive yard, complete with a large above-ground pool set into the ground, creating a private setting for summer entertaining, relaxation, and gatherings. Location is a major highlight! Just one block from Forest Avenue and Bement Avenue, you're surrounded by shopping, restaurants, banks, pharmacies, everyday conveniences, and more. Multiple bus options are nearby, while the expressway provides easy access to the Verrazzano-Narrows, Bayonne, and Goethals Bridges, making commuting throughout Staten Island and beyond a breeze. A wonderful opportunity to own a detached brick home on a desirable lot in one of Staten Island's established neighborhoods-bring your vision and make this West Brighton Cape your own!

Description from Realtor.com, shown as published there. See the original listing

Roofy listing score

Grade B, 73/100 · Complete

How complete and honest this listing is, from what the source sites show and Roofy’s own checks. It isn’t a rating of the home or the agent. How the score works

  • Photos25/25
    • Full points: 33 photos15/15
    • Full points: Large, clear photos (about 1,000 px)10/10
  • Details15/20
    • Full points: Price stated3/3
    • Full points: Bedrooms stated2/2
    • Full points: Bathrooms stated2/2
    • Full points: Size stated2/2
    • Does not apply: Move-in date: does not apply2/2
    • Does not apply: Lease length: does not apply1/1
    • No points: No pet policy0/1
    • No points: Laundry not mentioned0/1
    • No points: Heat and utilities not mentioned0/1
    • No points: No amenities listed0/2
    • Full points: Description of 242 words3/3
  • True cost11/15
    • Some points: Taxes not stated4/8
    • Full points: Price in line with similar homes in its neighborhood7/7
  • Accuracy12/15
    • Nothing to compare: Listed on one site, nothing to compare3/6
    • Full points: Agrees with city records (built 1950, 1 home)5/5
    • Full points: Confirmed on its source site 3 days ago4/4
  • Legal10/10
    • Full points: No fair-housing problems found in the wording6/6
    • Full points: The agent’s license is active4/4
  • Trust0/15
    • No points: Not claimed on Roofy by the agent or owner0/10
    • No points: The agent is not verified on Roofy0/5

Listed this home? Claim your agent page to add the trust points.

Scored Nov 2, 2026 · Score version 1. No one can pay to change a score.

Buying costs

What this price means for you each month, with the price filled in.

Compared with the area

Asks $699,999, 2% below the median asking price for 3-bedroom homes for sale in West New Brighton-Silver Lake-Grymes Hill.

Median here
$715,000
20 listings, last 90 days
Typical range
$599,650–$805,500
The middle half of listings
Per ft²
$536.81 vs $467.81
This home vs the median, 15% higher

Priced in line with similar homes here.

Asking prices of listings on Roofy and listing sites in the last 90 days, not signed leases or sale prices. One currency, never converted.

More about West New Brighton-Silver Lake-Grymes Hill

Location

Location as the listing shows it.Open in Google Maps

Nearby transit

  • StapletonSIR3.2 km
  • TompkinsvilleSIR3.2 km
  • St GeorgeSIR3.6 km

Nearby public schools · District 31

Distance only, not school zones. Check the zoned school with NYC Public Schools.

The building

1 unit · 2 floors · built 1950

Building record (NYC)

NYC records as of Nov 1 (weekly)

433 Sheffield Street · BBL 5-00166-0008 · built 1950 · 1 units

Roofy building score 96/100 · Well keptAbout the building, from HPD violations. Not an inspection.
Building type
One-family home
Open HPD violations
None
Heat complaints
0 this season
Complaints, last 12 months
0
Rent stabilization
None in 2018–2024 tax bills
Last sale (12-month file)
No sales in our 12-month file

No open immediately hazardous (Class C) violations.

See the full building record

Public NYC records about the building, not about the person listing it. Buyers and renters can see them on city websites too. Source: NYC Open Data (DCP PLUTO, HPD, DOF).

Added to Roofy Oct 29, 2026Last checked on Realtor.com Oct 29, 2026Roofy doesn’t verify listings. Never send money before seeing a home.

From Laura Volsario

Laura Volsario’s page →